Beach Bistro reopened on the sand at 6600 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach on Sept. 25. It had been closed for two years after Hurricane Helene damaged it in 2024. Few island restaurants are better known, and its return marks the second fall since the storms. It also shows a pattern in the recovery. The places that came back in roughly a year mostly gave something up to do it, whether a location, a name or a building. The places waiting to return to the exact spot where they stood in September 2024 are still waiting, or only just got back.
From Anna Maria to St. Armands Circle, the speed of each restaurant's return has tracked closely with how much it was willing to change.
The First Ones Back Changed Something
The Anna Maria Island Moose Lodge in Bradenton Beach was among the earliest. In late 2024 the AMI Sun reported that Helene's storm surge crashed through the Gulf-facing dining room windows and destroyed the exterior walls and everything inside them. The social quarters and bar at the south end of the building fared better. The lodge says it has more members than any other Moose lodge in the world, and it reopened in stages. The social quarters, bar and second-floor deck came back May 1, 2025, and the dining room followed about two months later. The lodge said at the time that FEMA's 50% repair-value rule and annual repair limits were delaying the full kitchen and dining room restoration.
On St. Armands Circle, Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar did not reopen in its old space. It held soft reopenings Sept. 23 and 24, 2025, and a grand reopening Nov. 5, 2025, at 465 John Ringling Blvd., the former home of Shore. Your Observer reported that the redesign added a roof opening on two sides and a new bar.
A few doors' worth of history away, Le Colonne came back with a new name. The family behind it reopened as Nōnnō Umberto, with a soft opening Dec. 29 and doors open by the first week of January 2026. While the restaurant was closed, they kept the business going with an Italian food truck. The new name honors the original owner's father, according to Your Observer.
The Rod & Reel took the biggest step. With the Rod & Reel Pier in Anna Maria badly damaged by Helene and mostly destroyed by Milton, owner Oliver "Oli" Lemke opened a 60-seat restaurant on dry land at 3246 East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach on Nov. 21, 2025. Within 15 minutes it was more than half full. "It took eight months to get this place ready," Lemke told the AMI Sun. "The money you spend here is going toward the rebuild of the pier."
| Spot | Came back as | Where it is now | Reopened |
|---|---|---|---|
| AMI Moose Lodge | Same lodge, in stages | Beachfront, Bradenton Beach | Bar and deck May 1, 2025, dining room about two months later |
| Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar | Redesigned restaurant in a different building | 465 John Ringling Blvd., St. Armands | Grand reopening Nov. 5, 2025 |
| The Rod & Reel | Inland stand-in for the pier | 3246 East Bay Drive, Holmes Beach | Nov. 21, 2025 |
| Le Colonne | Renamed Nōnnō Umberto | St. Armands Circle | Soft opening Dec. 29, 2025 |
| Beach Bistro | Same name, same sand | 6600 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach | Sept. 25, 2026 |
The last row is the outlier. Beach Bistro came back in the same building, under the same name, on the same beach. It took roughly twice as long as everyone else in the table.
Same Sand, Longer Wait
Beach Bistro returned with its classics unchanged, including the double lamb chop. Its signature four-course tasting menu is back too, now focused "more intently on whole food ingredients that grow naturally on Earth, making almost every item in-house, from scratch." The Sarasota Herald-Tribune's reopening story also lists new additions such as a crab cake appetizer.
The Rod & Reel Pier, the original the East Bay Drive restaurant is helping pay for, has not had a public update in a while. The most recent AMI Sun report, from November 2025, said the rebuild was still in permitting, with no construction start or reopening date announced. Inside the new restaurant, four screens hang under planks salvaged from the pier and show live video of what remains of it over Tampa Bay.
The Anna Maria City Pier is the other long wait at the north end. In August, WWSB reported that it was expected to reopen this fall after about two years closed. A new restaurant, PIERadise, will take the end of the pier. In June, the city had floated November as a tentative target if conditions held. The five-year lease approved for GSM Partners' PIERadise covers both the former City Pier Grill space and the adjacent former Mote space, with bait and tackle service and expanded dining planned. So even the pier that keeps its footprint is coming back with a new operator, a new name and more room.
Why the Original Spot Is the Slowest Place to Return
Shore shows why. Tommy Bahama now leases Shore's former building at 465 John Ringling Blvd. from restaurateur Tom Leonard, who still owns it. Leonard, working with the Kaufman development family, is trying to bring Shore back in a gutted two-story shell at the corner of Boulevard of the Presidents and Madison Drive. The plan calls for a boutique shop and casual cafe on the ground floor, the restaurant on the second level and a residential floor on top.
On Oct. 21, Your Observer reported that the project is caught on two readings of the city code. The partners plan to spend more than $200,000 dry-proofing the street level with aquarium glass rated to hold back floodwater or tidal surge. In St. Armands' Commercial Tourism district, though, dry-proofing caps building height at 35 feet. Wet-proofing, which lets water flow beneath an occupied space, allows 45 feet for residential structures. The second dispute is the second-story dining balcony, which staff treat like an awning that cannot extend past the property line. City staff also want clarity on parking: the building requires 17 on-site spaces and the plan shows 11.
"They're saying we want you to spend lots of money on dry floodproofing, but we're going to penalize you for doing that and not let you go to the same height if you allowed the water to flow through," project consultant Bill Waddill of Kimley-Horn told the Observer. A city spokesperson said the next step is for the applicant to resubmit, and that staff expect to discuss the concerns before then.
The rules differ from place to place, from the FEMA repair limits the Moose Lodge cited to the height, balcony and parking questions in front of Shore and the permitting the Rod & Reel Pier faces over open water. What they share is that a damaged waterfront building has to clear more review before it opens again. A restaurant that moves into a standing building or onto an inland lot skips much of that, and the timelines above match it. The Rod & Reel's inland restaurant took eight months to get ready, while the pier it replaced still has no start date.
Planning This Season Around the New Map
With seasonal visitors arriving and out-of-town guests on the calendar, here is how the reopened spots line up for an actual week:
- Breakfast or a casual lunch at The Rod & Reel, 3246 East Bay Drive. It's open seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m., with breakfast until 11 a.m. At opening last November the menu closely followed the old pier's, from fried clam strips at $16 and the Pier Burger at $15 to grouper sandwiches and garlic grouper at market price. Look for the pier mural and the original Rod & Reel Pier sign inside.
- A beachfront dinner at Beach Bistro, 6600 Gulf Drive. The four-course prix fixe ends with a dessert such as Dark Chocolate & Hazelnut Pot de Crème, Key Lime Pie or Passionfruit Panna Cotta. The Herald-Tribune has long counted the Bistro Bouillabaisse among its most popular dishes.
- A St. Armands evening that pairs Nōnnō Umberto with a look at the new Tommy Bahama. The redesigned Tommy Bahama at 465 John Ringling Blvd., with its partly open roof, is worth a walk-through even if you're eating Italian at Nōnnō Umberto.
- The Anna Maria City Pier and PIERadise, once they open. Reopening is expected this fall, and November was the city's tentative target as of June. The bait and tackle counter returns with it.
Shore's return to St. Armands depends on the next resubmittal to the city. The Rod & Reel Pier's rebuild depends on permits that were still being worked through at last report. Every bite at the East Bay Drive restaurant goes toward it, Lemke says.
At Costa Living, we follow waterfront rebuilds like these closely, because the same height, floodproofing and repair questions that shape a restaurant's comeback also come up on docks, seawalls and coastal homes. If you want to talk through what a waterfront rebuild involves, schedule a free consultation.